“The Professor and the Madman: A Tale of Murder, Insanity, and the Making of the Oxford English Dictionary” by Simon Winchester is a riveting exploration of the unlikely collaboration between two men, Dr. James Murray and Dr. William Chester Minor, who were instrumental in the creation of the Oxford English Dictionary (OED). This nonfiction work delves into the fascinating intersection of madness, genius, and scholarly achievement.
The Oxford English Dictionary, one of the most comprehensive and authoritative dictionaries in the world, was a monumental project that aimed to document the English language in its entirety. The project began in 1857 and took nearly seventy years to complete, with its first edition published in 1928. The dictionary’s creation required the contributions of thousands of volunteers who submitted definitions, quotations, and references to help catalog the vastness of the English language.
At the heart of the book is the extraordinary relationship between two men: Dr. James Murray, the primary editor of the OED, and Dr. William Chester Minor, one of the dictionary’s most prolific contributors. Dr. Murray, a brilliant linguist and scholar, was tasked with overseeing the monumental project, despite his humble beginnings and lack of formal education. His dedication to the OED was unmatched, and he worked tirelessly to ensure its success.
On the other side of this partnership was Dr. William Chester Minor, a retired American army surgeon who lived in England. Unbeknownst to Murray and many others involved in the project, Minor was a convicted murderer and inmate at the Broadmoor Asylum for the Criminally Insane. Despite his troubled past and ongoing mental illness, Minor possessed a sharp intellect and a deep passion for literature, making him an invaluable contributor to the OED.
Minor’s contributions to the dictionary were extensive. He provided thousands of quotations and references, meticulously recorded from the hundreds of books he had in his possession. His work was so significant that Dr. Murray eventually sought to meet him in person. When the two finally met, Murray was stunned to discover that Minor was not only an inmate at Broadmoor but also suffered from severe delusions and paranoia.
The story of “The Professor and the Madman” is not just about the creation of the Oxford English Dictionary; it is also about the complex relationship between madness and genius. Winchester carefully weaves together the personal histories of Murray and Minor, highlighting their shared passion for language and scholarship.
The book delves into Minor’s troubled past, exploring how his experiences as a surgeon during the American Civil War may have contributed to his mental instability. Winchester also examines the Victorian era’s attitudes toward mental illness and the treatment of the criminally insane, providing a broader context for Minor’s story.
Despite his mental illness, Minor was a man of immense intellect and dedication. His meticulous contributions to the OED, all made from his cell in the asylum, were crucial to the dictionary’s success. The book explores the irony that a man labeled as insane played such a vital role in one of the greatest intellectual achievements of the time.
Winchester’s narrative is rich with historical detail, bringing to life the arduous process of compiling the dictionary. He describes the meticulous work of collecting, verifying, and organizing the vast number of words and quotations submitted by volunteers. The project was a massive undertaking that required not only scholarly rigor but also a deep love for the English language.
One of the central themes of the book is the redemptive power of intellectual work. For Dr. Minor, contributing to the OED provided a sense of purpose and a way to channel his troubled mind. His work on the dictionary was not only a scholarly pursuit but also a form of therapy. Through his contributions, Minor found a way to connect with the world beyond the walls of the asylum, even as he battled his inner demons.
The relationship between Murray and Minor is also a testament to the power of empathy and understanding. Despite learning about Minor’s criminal past and mental illness, Murray continued to value his contributions and treated him with respect and kindness. Their unlikely friendship, forged through a shared love of language, is one of the most poignant aspects of the book.
“The Professor and the Madman” is not just a story about the making of a dictionary; it is a reflection on the human condition. It explores the thin line between madness and genius, the redemptive power of intellectual work, and the capacity for compassion and understanding. Winchester’s masterful storytelling brings to life the lives of two remarkable men whose unlikely partnership created one of the most important literary works of all time.
Review
Simon Winchester’s “The Professor and the Madman” is a compelling and beautifully written account of an extraordinary chapter in literary history. Winchester excels at blending historical narrative with psychological insight, creating a story that is both informative and deeply moving. The book’s strength lies in its ability to humanize its subjects, particularly Dr. William Chester Minor, whose tragic story is handled with sensitivity and nuance.
Winchester’s prose is elegant and accessible, making complex historical and linguistic topics engaging for a wide audience. The book’s structure, which alternates between the lives of Murray and Minor and the broader history of the OED, keeps the reader engaged and provides a comprehensive understanding of the dictionary’s creation. While the book is meticulously researched, it never feels dry or overly academic. Instead, Winchester’s narrative style brings history to life, making “The Professor and the Madman” a compelling read for anyone interested in language, history, or the human psyche.
The book has been praised for its insightful exploration of the relationship between madness and genius, as well as its thoughtful treatment of mental illness. However, some readers have noted that the book occasionally strays into tangential historical details that, while interesting, may detract from the central narrative. Overall, “The Professor and the Madman” is a fascinating and thought-provoking read that offers a unique perspective on the creation of one of the most important reference works in the English language.
Read the Full Novel Here
About the Author
Simon Winchester is a British author, journalist, and broadcaster known for his extensive body of work, which includes both nonfiction and fiction. Born in 1944, Winchester has had a distinguished career in journalism, working for publications such as The Guardian and The Sunday Times.
He has written numerous bestselling books, including “The Map That Changed the World,” “The Man Who Loved China,” and “The Men Who United the States.” Winchester’s writing is characterized by his meticulous research, engaging narrative style, and ability to bring historical events to life for modern readers. He was awarded the Order of the British Empire (OBE) for his services to journalism and literature.
