“Chasing the Scream: The First and Last Days of the War on Drugs” by Johann Hari is a thought-provoking exploration of one of the most controversial and damaging global policies: the war on drugs. Hari delves into the history, failures, and human stories behind this policy, offering an alternative perspective on addiction, drug laws, and criminal justice.
The book opens with a reflection on the origins of the war on drugs, tracing it back to January 17, 1914, when the United States government passed the Harrison Narcotics Tax Act. Hari presents this as the first major event in what would become a century-long battle against drugs. He introduces readers to Harry Anslinger, the first commissioner of the Federal Bureau of Narcotics, who played a significant role in shaping America’s drug policy and rhetoric. Anslinger’s fierce anti-drug crusade is depicted as racially motivated, rooted in fear and prejudice, especially against African Americans and Latinos.
As the narrative unfolds, Hari provides detailed profiles of people impacted by the war on drugs. One such person is Billie Holiday, the legendary jazz singer whose struggles with addiction were exacerbated by Anslinger’s relentless pursuit. Her tragic story exemplifies the cruel ways in which the criminalization of drugs harmed individuals and marginalized communities.
Hari doesn’t only focus on the enforcers of drug laws; he also turns his lens toward those who have fought against the punitive system. In contrasting the harshness of the drug war, he introduces readers to figures like Dr. João Goulão, who was instrumental in Portugal’s decision to decriminalize drugs. Hari describes how, in 2001, Portugal became the first country to decriminalize all drugs, shifting from treating addiction as a crime to seeing it as a public health issue. The results have been promising, with a sharp decrease in drug-related deaths and a more humane approach to dealing with addicts.
A crucial element of “Chasing the Scream” is the exploration of the science of addiction. Hari challenges the long-standing belief that addiction is simply the result of chemical hooks in drugs. He presents research showing that social isolation and disconnection are often the root causes of addiction. In an iconic experiment called Rat Park, which Hari discusses, rats were given the choice between regular water and drug-laced water. In isolation, they consistently chose the drug, but when placed in an enriched environment with other rats and stimulating activities, they largely avoided it. This finding suggests that a lack of social bonds and meaningful life experiences are driving forces behind addiction, not just the substances themselves.
Hari’s exploration takes readers across the globe, from the streets of Vancouver, where he meets a woman named Lisa, who sells sex to fund her addiction, to Mexico, where the drug cartels have ravaged entire communities. One of the most shocking stories Hari uncovers is that of Rosalio Reta, a hitman for a Mexican drug cartel, who started killing for the cartel when he was just a teenager. Through such stories, Hari reveals the human cost of the drug war, which extends far beyond those directly involved in the drug trade. Families, communities, and entire nations have been torn apart by violence, corruption, and the vast resources diverted to enforcing prohibition.
“Chasing the Scream” also highlights the hypocrisy and contradictions within drug policies. Hari examines the cultural acceptability of certain drugs, like alcohol, compared to the demonization of others like marijuana or heroin. He argues that the lines drawn between legal and illegal substances are often arbitrary and politically motivated, rather than based on harm or scientific evidence.
In his investigation, Hari looks at alternatives to the current approach, examining harm-reduction models and the benefits of decriminalization. He provides compelling evidence that decriminalizing and regulating drugs, rather than banning them outright, would not only reduce crime and violence but also better address the root causes of addiction. By treating drug use as a health issue rather than a criminal one, societies can reduce the stigma attached to addiction and provide more effective help for those in need.
Ultimately, “Chasing the Scream” is not just a critique of the war on drugs but a call for a profound shift in how we think about drugs, addiction, and criminal justice. Hari presents a compelling argument that punitive measures have failed, and in their place, a compassionate, evidence-based approach could provide a better solution. He concludes with a vision of a world where drug users are supported, not punished, and where the devastating cycle of violence, addiction, and criminalization is broken.
Review of “Chasing the Scream”
Johann Hari’s “Chasing the Scream” is a deeply engaging and powerful book that challenges conventional wisdom about drugs and addiction. The writing is clear, persuasive, and often heart-wrenching as Hari introduces readers to real people whose lives have been affected by the war on drugs. His global perspective, combined with meticulous research and emotional storytelling, makes the book both informative and gripping.
Critics have praised Hari for his ability to weave together historical analysis, scientific research, and personal stories into a cohesive narrative that paints a vivid picture of the failures of current drug policies. The book’s message—that the war on drugs has caused more harm than good—is well-supported by evidence, and Hari offers realistic solutions for reform.
However, some readers have pointed out that the book’s ambitious scope sometimes means that certain aspects are not fully explored. For example, while Hari does a fantastic job highlighting the failures of prohibition, he could have delved deeper into the complexities of implementing the alternatives he suggests. Yet, these are minor quibbles in an otherwise excellent and important book.
For those interested in social justice, drug policy, or simply understanding more about the global impacts of addiction and law enforcement, “Chasing the Scream” is essential reading.
Read the Full Novel Here
Chasing the Scream: The First and Last Days of the War on Drugs by Johann Hari | Goodreads
About the Author
Johann Hari is a British writer and journalist known for his investigative work and thought-provoking perspectives on complex social issues. He has written for publications such as The New York Times, The Independent, and The Guardian. Hari’s focus on mental health, addiction, and drug policy has earned him international recognition. “Chasing the Scream,” his second book, solidified his reputation as a compassionate and thorough investigator of human struggles. His later works, including “Lost Connections,” continue to explore the causes of mental health crises and societal disconnection.
