“Case Closed: Lee Harvey Oswald and the Assassination of JFK” is a meticulously researched book by Gerald Posner that seeks to dispel the numerous conspiracy theories surrounding the assassination of President John F. Kennedy. Published in 1993, the book gained significant attention for its bold assertion that Lee Harvey Oswald acted alone in killing the President on November 22, 1963. Posner, using a wealth of evidence, including government documents, interviews, and testimonies, refutes many of the long-standing doubts about Oswald’s role and his connections to other entities, such as the CIA, KGB, or organized crime.
The Core Argument
The central thesis of Posner’s book is that despite the abundance of theories suggesting otherwise, the evidence overwhelmingly points to Oswald as the lone shooter. He dissects Oswald’s background, his psychological profile, and his movements leading up to the assassination to build a case that Oswald had the motive, means, and opportunity to commit the crime. Posner explores Oswald’s troubled childhood, his defection to the Soviet Union, and his subsequent disillusionment before returning to the United States. He paints a picture of a man who lived in a self-created fantasy world, seeking recognition and validation through radical political beliefs and erratic behavior.
Debunking the Conspiracies
Posner spends a significant portion of the book analyzing and debunking various conspiracy theories that have emerged since Kennedy’s assassination. The author systematically addresses theories suggesting Oswald was a patsy for the mafia, a secret agent for the CIA, or manipulated by other covert organizations. Posner argues that these theories lack credible evidence and are often based on conjecture, misinterpretations, or fabricated stories.
For instance, the theory that the CIA was involved is countered by Posner through evidence showing that Oswald was regarded as mentally unstable by both American and Soviet intelligence agencies. His defection to the Soviet Union and subsequent disappointment there indicate a personal rather than an orchestrated motive. Similarly, Posner dismisses the idea of multiple shooters in Dealey Plaza by analyzing the trajectory of the bullets and medical reports that confirm a single-shooter scenario.
The Zapruder Film and Medical Evidence
One of the pivotal pieces of evidence in Posner’s argument is the analysis of the infamous Zapruder film, which captured the assassination. Posner uses this footage, along with other photographic and forensic evidence, to reconstruct the sequence of events that led to Kennedy’s death. He also references the findings of the Warren Commission and the House Select Committee on Assassinations, emphasizing that despite some discrepancies in these reports, the conclusions about Oswald’s sole responsibility remain consistent.
Posner also delves into the autopsy reports and ballistic evidence, dispelling the notion that the fatal bullet could not have been fired from the Texas School Book Depository, where Oswald was positioned. By addressing inconsistencies and clarifying ambiguities in the medical examinations, Posner strengthens his assertion that Oswald acted alone.
Jack Ruby and the Murder of Oswald
Another critical aspect of the book is Posner’s exploration of Jack Ruby’s role in the aftermath of the assassination. Ruby, a nightclub owner, shot Oswald two days after the assassination, fueling further suspicions of a conspiracy. Posner examines Ruby’s background, his motivations, and his behavior in the days leading up to Oswald’s murder. He concludes that Ruby acted impulsively and was not part of a larger plot to silence Oswald. Posner’s depiction of Ruby as an emotionally unstable and attention-seeking individual aligns with his broader theme that both Oswald and Ruby acted independently.
Legacy and Impact of “Case Closed”
“Case Closed” stirred considerable debate upon its release, as it challenged many entrenched beliefs about the Kennedy assassination. Critics of the book argue that Posner’s reliance on government documents and official reports undermines the credibility of his conclusions, especially given the distrust that exists around these sources. However, supporters of Posner’s work commend his rigorous analysis and methodical approach to dismantling conspiracy theories.
The book remains a significant contribution to the field of JFK assassination studies, providing a comprehensive rebuttal to the myriad of theories that have proliferated over the decades. Posner’s work has encouraged a re-examination of the evidence and has sparked renewed discussions about the nature of historical truth and the allure of conspiracy thinking.
Review of “Case Closed”
“Case Closed” has been praised for its clear and compelling narrative. Posner’s writing is accessible, and he manages to break down complex information into digestible segments. Reviewers have noted that while the book may not convince die-hard conspiracy theorists, it offers a persuasive case for those open to re-evaluating the events of November 22, 1963. Posner’s skillful use of evidence, combined with his ability to weave a cohesive story, makes “Case Closed” a compelling read for anyone interested in one of America’s most enduring mysteries.
However, the book has also faced criticism. Some readers feel that Posner dismisses alternative theories too readily, without giving adequate consideration to conflicting evidence. Others argue that his reliance on government sources undermines his credibility, as these sources have been questioned and reinterpreted over the years.
Overall, “Case Closed” stands out as a definitive work for those seeking an in-depth, evidence-based exploration of the JFK assassination and the life of Lee Harvey Oswald.
Read the Full Novel Here
Case Closed: Lee Harvey Oswald and the Assassination of JFK by Gerald Posner | Goodreads
About the Author
Gerald Posner is an investigative journalist and author known for his meticulous research and thorough analysis of controversial topics. Born in 1954, Posner graduated from the University of California, Berkeley, and later received his law degree from Hastings Law School. His career has spanned decades, during which he has published numerous books covering topics ranging from political assassinations to corporate malfeasance. Posner’s work often focuses on debunking myths and clarifying complex historical events, making him a prominent figure in investigative journalism.
With “Case Closed,” Posner cemented his reputation as a fearless investigator willing to tackle contentious subjects with precision and clarity. His dedication to uncovering the truth has earned him both acclaim and criticism, reflecting the divisive nature of his work.
