“Why Do We Kill? The Pathology of Murder in Baltimore,” co-authored by former Baltimore City homicide detective Kelvin Sewell and investigative journalist Stephen Janis, offers a compelling exploration of the reasons behind Baltimore’s high homicide rate. This book stands out for its unique perspective: a seasoned detective’s firsthand account, complemented by a journalist’s in-depth context, providing an eye-opening narrative about the systemic issues plaguing Baltimore.
The book delves into the stories of some of Baltimore’s most notorious homicides over the past decade, showcasing the harrowing violence and the complexity of each case. Through Sewell’s detailed recounts and Janis’s investigative expertise, readers are guided through the psychological, social, and economic factors contributing to violent crime in the city. From gang-related murders to crimes of passion and desperation, the book sheds light on the harsh realities that often go unseen by the public.
One of the central themes is the dehumanizing effect of violence—not just on the victims but also on the community and law enforcement officers tasked with solving these crimes. The narrative unveils a city riddled with social dysfunction, where crime becomes a symptom of broader systemic failures like poverty, lack of education, and inadequate mental health support.
“Why Do We Kill?” is structured around specific cases, such as a gang member being burned alive and a baby buried by its own mother, providing raw insights into the circumstances that lead individuals to commit such heinous acts. The authors don’t simply recount these stories; they analyze the motives and environments that create murderers. By focusing on personal stories and real cases, the book humanizes both victims and perpetrators, creating a nuanced view of crime.
The book also discusses the impact of crime on the city’s law enforcement. Sewell’s narrative captures the psychological toll on detectives who, despite working tirelessly, struggle to comprehend the senseless violence and overwhelming despair they witness daily. This is further accentuated by Janis’s commentary, which contextualizes the stories within Baltimore’s history of economic downturns, racial tensions, and political corruption.
What makes the book particularly powerful is its collaborative voice. Sewell provides the gritty reality of a homicide detective’s life, sharing his thoughts on cases he personally worked on. Janis, on the other hand, uses his journalistic skills to add depth, context, and analysis to these stories. This dual perspective results in a narrative that is both personal and analytical, providing readers with a comprehensive understanding of why violence persists in Baltimore.
The book doesn’t shy away from confronting misconceptions about crime in Baltimore. Instead, it aims to dispel myths by providing the truth as seen through the eyes of those on the front lines. This approach creates an authentic, compelling, and at times heartbreaking portrait of a city in crisis.
“Why Do We Kill?” has received praise for its candid and unfiltered portrayal of Baltimore’s crime scene. Many reviewers commend the book for its depth of analysis and its ability to articulate the struggles faced by law enforcement in one of America’s most violent cities. The book’s strength lies in its storytelling—each case is handled with care, making the reader feel the weight of every death and the frustration of every unsolved case.
Critics also appreciate the book’s ability to balance the emotional toll of these stories with factual analysis. The combination of Sewell’s firsthand experiences and Janis’s journalistic approach gives the book a credibility and authenticity that is rare in true crime literature. However, some have noted that the graphic nature of the cases may be overwhelming for sensitive readers.
Stephen Janis is an award-winning journalist and co-founder of Investigative Voice, an independent news website focused on watchdog journalism in Baltimore. He previously worked as a staff writer for the Baltimore Examiner and has won multiple Maryland-Delaware-DC Press Association awards for his crime reporting. His experience covering unsolved murders and police corruption has made him a respected voice in the field of investigative journalism.
Kelvin Sewell is a 22-year veteran of the Baltimore Police Department and a former narcotics officer assigned to the U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration. His extensive experience in homicide investigations provides a unique lens through which to understand the nature of violent crime in urban environments. Sewell’s dedication to uncovering the truth and exposing the factors that lead to criminal behavior has made him a valuable voice in the conversation about crime and justice in America.
Why Do We Kill?: The Pathology of Murder in Baltimore by Stephen Janis | Goodreads
“Why Do We Kill?” is more than just a true crime book. It’s an exploration of the pathology of violence and an examination of a city caught in a cycle of death and despair. For readers interested in understanding the deeper causes of crime, this book provides an unflinching look at the intersection of personal tragedy, social failure, and systemic dysfunction. It’s a must-read for those seeking to grasp the complexities of crime beyond the headlines and for anyone who wants to understand the human cost of violence in Baltimore.
This book goes beyond the simple question of “why” and ventures into the harrowing reality of what happens when crime becomes a way of life for an entire city.
Signs You’re Growing Apart Introduction Every relationship goes through its ups and downs, but sometimes,…
Capital punishment, a phrase that sends shivers down the spines of some and a sense…
Burning Embers Introduction Katie May's "Burning Embers" transports readers to a seemingly ordinary town harboring…
The story of Jesus Christ is not just a tale of a man who lived…
The Impact of Social Media on Relationships Introduction In today’s digital age, social media is…
When it comes to sports, having the right earbuds can make a significant difference in…